Wednesday, 18 January 2012

Please be silent behind the screen


Being able to see a silent film showcased around the globe is quite a unique experience in 2012 – made possible by a French filmmaker Michel Hazanavicius. He writes a loving black & white postcard to an art form unjustifiably perished in the 20th century. Heartfelt, charming and concluded with a happy ending, it manages to leave lasting feel-good impression with hint nostalgia for the genre. And while the storyline of the film should be known to most media-aware individuals, there are other values The Artist manages to bring to the table.

Thoroughly well received at film festivals in 2011 the unusual (if not extinct) awards contender has earned its lead Jean Dujardin the Best Actor gig in Cannes. A few actors could truly embrace the role without making it look like a pantomime and Dujardin plays George Valentin rather brilliantly. And although roles in The Artist were written for its actors, Valentin never looks like a contemporary protagonist transferred to 1927 Hollywood setting – a danger every modern script attempting to embody the essence of the silent era will come across. Petite Berenice Bejo is equally charming as Peppy Miller and both – the actress and her character – have an ability to light up the screen of any colour. Hazanvicius has thus made a clever move by casting relatively unknown actors. He wants us to see the film because of the art form it salutes, and not because of the star power someone might bring to the box-office. But how many people will actually dare to see it? How many will leave their stereotypical perceptions behind and choose The Artist over latest instalments in the never-ending Mission Impossible saga or Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows?

Screening of The Artist at 3pm in a buzzing shopping mall gathers 14 people – 4 couples past their 50ies, who have grown up watching silent films, and 6 younger females on their own. Ironically, pre-screening commercial questions: “Why do I go to the cinema?” to soon come upon an answer – “For the experience”, setting off The Artist the best way possible. It salutes the cinema of attractions with its every take, bringing us back to the heyday of cinema when watching moving images on screen used to be an event, an EXPERIENCE. It was simple and extraordinary in its ability to unite and entertain, in its purpose – to show. And maybe Hazanvicius is onto something else here – maybe the cinema these days does say too much without really saying anything?

Hollywood won’t miss an opportunity to cash in on the ‘novelty’ while the idea is still hot – expect black & white sequences in the upcoming releases and possible references to the genre in American parodies. With 6 Golden Globes noms, 3 wins and all the Oscar-buzz surrounding the picture (which has a good chance of becoming the first silent film to pick up the main award since Wings in 1927), it has surely become bigger than Hazanavicius has ever expected. Let’s hope the success of The Artist won’t turn the film against everything it represents. It is, after all, called The Artist for a reason.


The Artist is out in cinemas now. Go see it while you can!


Friday, 9 December 2011

Melancholia as a scar



          Lars Von Trier’s latest movie Melancholia (2011) looks like a painting and reads like a poem. It is, however, blurring boundaries not only of cinematic genres, but also presenting alternative tools for their delivery. The image of an apocalypse in a post 9/11 cinema appears marked by destruction and melancholy, and although the title of Von Trier’s film suggests sheer sadness, it is also a (fascinatingly) beautiful apocalyptic tale balancing between life and death. Melancholia starts and ends with the ultimate culmination - fin de siècle while its border is drawn by the notion of acceptance. This paper will therefore explore apocalyptic boundaries highlighted in the film and look at their significance within a rather unique context produced by a Danish director and screenwriter Von Trier.

          Melancholia begins with an 8min slow-motion prologue where the opening close-up shot of Justine reveals birds falling from the sunset stricken sky and moves on to illustrate a descending  painting of a village, eventually coming to an image of  a red star approaching the Earth – all to Richard Wagner’s prelude to “Tristan and Isolde”. A woman holding a child runs through a golf course seemingly drowning in its marshy grass, a horse stumbles to the ground and Justine appears again – this time in a long shot surrounded by butterflies and snow-flakes. But this dreamy cinematography is not an overture for a happy ending – Justine examines her hands shedding light in a medium shot and is afterwards seen running through the forest trying to avoid its ensnaring branches. Another planet is shortly seen coming into view and we know the Earth is about to end. We see the collision and a dark screen before the narrative resumes back to the start.
          Von Trier has divided his film into two segments: “Justine” and “Claire”, thus placing sisters as binary oppositions alongside contrasting issues of life & death, happiness & sadness, The Earth & Melancholia. Film’s tone consequently often shifts between science fiction, disaster and drama. Sukhdev Sandhu’s review in the Telegraph describes the overall feel of Melancholia best:
 The film seethes with ideas, darkness, bruising soulfulness, visual invention. Its monstrous conceit, its excess and complexity, its sheer unreasonableness: this is cinema that refuses to know its place, that doesn’t cater to an instant-response. But make no mistake: this is cinema as scar.
Most of it is filmed with a handheld camera in a way that we see the events unfold through character’s point-of-view. This adds a familiar, almost documentary feel to the picture while shots produced by a steady positioned camera take us to the dreadful, yet beautiful unknown. In “The sense of an ending” author Stephen Keane reminds readers that ‘it is important to remember that the disaster genre has always been based around familiarity and novelty (2001:76). Death is therefore a novelty in a form of impending doom which suddenly casts a shadow upon family’s familiar surroundings. But what makes Melancholia different from other disaster/ sci-fi films?  

          As pointed out by film critic Roger Ebert, ‘Von Trier limits himself entirely to the meandering conversations at the house party. He avoids all the usual sci-fi clichés; there are no TV news updates, no Cabinet meetings, no nuclear rockets fired at it, no surging mobs in the streets. It looms larger. It "appeared from behind the sun (www.rogerebert.suntimes.com).”’ This portrayal of an apocalyptic dread is not only Von Trier’s autheuristic statement but also his critique of the traditional Hollywood cinema dealing with existential fear and life in the future.
Firstly, he avoids the ‘terror in the big city’ scenario where panic spreads amongst the population, buildings collapse as people try to run or hide and more importantly – fight. Altogether, he avoids mass destruction and unfamiliar casualties. Instead, he offers a quiet countryside villa to focus viewer’s attention on a few characters inhibiting it as a result. We do not know about the outside world and its reaction towards the approaching event since the off-screen space is guarded by carefully chosen dialogues between those characters. No one makes hysteric good-bye calls or invites loved-ones for a last get-together. It is obvious that the apocalypse happens globally but we are told about it through a closeted cinematic space.
Moreover and secondly, the absence of media plays with the portrayal of scopic dread – the dread of looking. Von Trier masterfully unites estranged family members as oppose to creating global solidarity via universally panic-ridden television broadcasts (which would only boast anxiety and fear). According to Thompson,
Scopic dread is concerned with what is unseen, but which [...] metonymically points out to something which is already there (2007:138).
They know it’s coming. In fact, they can see it coming, but they decide not to almost till the very end – and the only response to the unseen derives from human emotions, not news stories or collective fright (e.g. 2012, Day After Tomorrow). This style of filmmaking is thus empathizing not only on isolation between characters and the outside world, but also segregates cinemagoers so as they become somewhat intimately bond to the scenery in return.
Regardless, it comes as a surprise when Claire enters dreading words “melancholia” and “death” in a search engine, simply seeking a confirmation of what she already knows. This proves that Von Trier is not denying the role media and technology may play should the worst happen– yet he’s showing it can be used differently...if not more privately. All in all, by doing so he succeeds in telling the story of apocalypse without conventional mise-en-scene (‘terror in the big city’ )and violence of the mass media.
Thirdly, the director keeps away from typecasting a hero who’s going to save the world, which in a classical Hollywood narrative would have been a well-known white male (e.g. Bruce Willis in Surrogates, Fifth Element and Armageddon, Keanu Reeves in The Matrix trilogy or Tom Cruise in Minority Report and War of the Worlds). In contrast, Von Trier favours complicated female protagonists who are so distressed from within that they embrace danger when it comes. Yet again, these women do not fight aliens, robots or Mother Nature – they excel in an inner fight with the inevitable. Male characters are, however, present for a while and leave the narrative in almost comic way: Justine’s new husband Michael departs unable to cope with the odd behaviour of his wife on their wedding night whereas Claire’s scientist husband John commits suicide realizing that the end is near. If men are meant to be strong and powerful and women – helpless and weak – then Von Trier swiftly changes the order of these oppositions in a way only a few filmmakers can.

          Furthermore, since women are driving the narrative it is worth looking at leading martyr-heroine characters closer. The first segment shows Justine (played by Kirsten Dunst) as a beautiful bride approaching wedding reception with her newly wed husband Michael. Her striking exterior, however, hides a troubled and alienated individual who, as the night proves, finds transcendence in masochism along with some other weird choices – such as disappearing to urinate in the garden, taking a bath midway through reception or spontaneously raping a new colleague. Nevertheless, Justine is the only one to notice a red star in the sky and so her depression only grows deeper as it approaches. She doesn’t seem to care about the pricey wedding or her new husband, and descends into a memory of the forthcoming future as if she had envisioned a previously mentioned prologue before. Justine mourns the loss of life before it even happens and thus alienates herself from the crowd while her tradition-hating mother Gaby ironically proclaims: “enjoy it while it lasts!” And she will, in the most masochistic way possible.
In mourning it is the world which has become poor and empty; in melancholia it is the ego itself (Freud, 1957:246).
Indeed, melancholia is not only the name of a planet hurtling towards the Earth to destroy it; it is also a state of mind which Freud talks about in "Mourning and Melancholia". Ironically, we do not know which truly destroys Justine. But while the lost object in Freudian terms is another life, our protagonist narcissistically mourns her own. She claims to “know things”...and she knows that “life is only on Earth” and that it is “evil.” In fact, mourning and self-torture are her answers to anxiety and fear, converting into acceptance when she finally gets out of bed to witness the end instead of hiding away.

          Claire (Charlotte Gainsbourg), on the other hand, initially appears as Justine’s opposite: she is calm, optimistic and organized. She oozes balance during the chaotic wedding and takes care of her fading sister, only to fall into despair when coming to understand the darker recess of her own humanity. Claire was blindfolded believing her husband when rumours of the two planets colliding started to spread. “Trust me, I’m a scientist” he said, before cowardly committing an act of taking his own life. Seeing is believing – and Claire’s denial was overshadowed by evidence. As said by Sigmund Freud,
The interdependence of the complicated problems of the mind forces us to break off every enquiry before it is completed—till the outcome of some other enquiry can come to its assistance (1957:285).
She also mourns her loss, but her previously serene persona will have a longer journey towards acceptance. Subsequently, the two sisters exchange personalities and it is now Justine who’s holding Claire’s trembling hand in the ‘magic cave’ whilst Melancholia enters the planetary boundary layer.

          Lars Von Trier adds another twist to the narrative – as he is usually known to do (e.g. talking self-destructive foxes in the Antichrist) in order to confuse the spectator. John confronts irritable Justine during the party, concluding with a seemingly random question:
“How many holes are on the golf course?”
-          “18”, she answers.
Nevertheless, one of the final shots produces an image of Claire and her son Leo falling to the ground on a golf course – next to the 19th hole. On one hand, golfers speak about the nineteenth hole when the game is finished and they gather for a drink at the clubhouse. Another explanation is found in the 80ies TV series Knight Rider where it is used as a slang term - meaning the place where they bury people who get in the way. With Von Trier, though, this idea has to be explored further. Does he refer to life as a game which eventually finishes? Or is he comparing Melancholia’s arrival to the golf ball which, having reached the final hole, plummets into nothingness? And finally, is the nineteenth hole the end or, possibly, a new beginning? This scene toys with the viewer as much as film’s revealing prologue which discloses its finale before the main body of work, and presents life & death in a different light yet again.

          Two planets. Two sisters. Life and death. Von Trier succeeds in delivering his vision of apocalypse through contrasts and binary oppositions. He avoids cinematic clichés of the genre and focuses on the inner journey towards acceptance. It’s a dark, yet visually enriched and therefore beautiful poem about The End of the World, the magnitude of which eventually blurs all boundaries. All the more, Melancholia does not rule out that death might be only the end of a poem before the new chapter begins; hitherto we are left with a black screen and a scar...for now, at least.

Bibliography:
Ebert, R. (2011) “Melancholia: by Roger Ebert”, Chicago Sunday Times online, 9th Nov, viewed 7th December 2011,

Freud, S. (1957) "Mourning and Melancholia", Standard Edition of The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, vol. 14. London, England: Hogarth Press

Keane, S. (2001) “The sense of an ending”, Disaster Movies: The Cinema of Catastrophe, London: Wallflower

 Sandhu S. (2011) Melancholia review, The Telegraph, 29th Sept, viewed 7th December 2011,

Thompson, K. M. (2007) Apocalyptic Dread: American Film at the Turn of the Millennium, Albany: State University of New York Press
TheGiO (user) (2011), Melancholia Prologue video, YouTube, 2nd Oct, viewed 8th December 2011,


Filmography:
Melancholia (Von Trier, 2011, Denmark/Sweden/France/Germany)

Monday, 21 November 2011

... ... ... ''Wanna get out of here?''




Crazy Stupid Love (dir. Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, 2011) is exactly what it sounds like – another relationship-mocking rom-com. Insert a bit of heart and a few male characters unhappily in love instead of traditionally distressed women, and you get a watchable film with Steve Carell, Ryan Gosling, Julianne Moore and Emma Stone leading the pack.

Carell plays Moore’s husband Cal Weaver who has been “buying the wrong size suit for 20 years” and whose wife has thus ordered a divorce for dessert (no pricetag for that one-bummer!). Oh, and there’s this David Lindhagen (cameo by Kevin Bacon) guy who plays the third wheel, but we’ll be hearing that name a lot in the context...be warned! Having overheard Cal crying in the bathroom his boss is pleased to point out it’s not cancer, ONLY a divorce...but that’s where films irony only starts to emerge. Cal’s 13-year old son Robbie (Jonah Bobo) is in love with his slightly older nanny Jessica (ANTM graduate Analeigh Tipton) while she has hots for the newly divorced daddy himself. Complicated yet? It only gets better.

Unable to forgive & forget (and somewhat returning to his 4o year old virgin self) Carell’s character starts heading to a bar where he witnesses Ryan Gosling’s Jacob leave with a different girl every night. Surprisingly...ok, not really, but still: macho man himself offers help in finding Cal’s manhood yet again. In reality, he must be as tired of hearing Lindhagen’s name as the rest of us. The credit cards then come in handy and Cal soon becomes and older version Jacob himself...on the outside at least. He still wants to get back with the missus and live happily ever after (stupid, but not crazy, and most certainly L.O.V.E.) and, luckily for Cal, it only takes bedding 9 women in the process. Lindhagen can’t beat that!

Feminists might erupt in fury at the sight of women in the bar who appear to be nothing more than sexual objects, falling for Jacob’s cheesy lines like bees for honey. That certainly is the first impression until...let’s face it: the film indirectly critiques those who decide to wake up the morning after as oppose to denying the “wanna get out of here?” invite. Head to your nearest bar for evidence and witness a real-life irony of the narrative in Crazy Stupid Love (in your own time).

It is still a misery to me why has Golsing – who’s gradually building a reputation of an indie king – chosen the role of Jacob? Was he looking for an easy way to establish himself as the Hollywood’s ‘it boy’? Whatever the reason, ladies will certainly take notice while critics may dwell on limitations of this macho man character. Either way – notice taken twice!

Ficarra and Requa might not have made the best rom-com ever and neither were they aiming to do so. Regardless, it is a very watchable piece with a dash of irony and occasional laughs just where they belong. Not an eye-opener, but, hey, at least someone has made a good joke about what’s become of old-school first dates and romance altogether.
Predictably (spoiler alert), those not looking for love find it eventually and those with a broken heart get cured. Yet you cannot help but wonder: why do men get through the relationship drama easier and with, err, more grace?





Wednesday, 9 November 2011



The Only Edward I’ll Ever Love Has Scissors For Hands


INTRO

Humanity has truly come a long way – built cities, formed countries and languages, invented and destroyed. Yet there are timeless issues which we have not mastered to address – and dealing with otherness in the society is certainly one of them. The topic has been approached by many filmmakers, but I’d like to focus this paper on Tim Burton’s Edward Scissorhands (1990) - a film which also reflects on director’s personal experiences growing up in Burbank, California and not being able to find a sense of belonging in its suburban community. It is a dark modern day fairy-tale telling a story of a misperceived individual Edward who has scissors for hands thus criticizing social conformity and its inability to accept otherness.


WHERE DO YOU COME FROM?

Edward’s alienation becomes evident instantly. He comes from a dark mansion on top of the hill where his scientist-father had died before completing his creation with regular hands. We do not know how long Edward has been observing the town and neither do we know if he ever wanted to escape isolation, but Peg’s arrival gives him a chance to become a part of community for the first time. Consequently, film’s director Tim Burton creates an illusion of two contrasting worlds through films colourful imagery and his Gothic protagonist which spawn stronger atmosphere than meaningless action or long dialogues. As argued by Manuel Aguirre, ‘One of the identifying features of the continually shifting definition of the Gothic is the fascination with thresholds and boundaries, the places where two worlds and two kinds of experience meet. One of the key ways this idea is explored in Gothic narratives is through placing ‘ordinary people in “extraordinary positions (in Bloom, 2007:235)”’. For that reason much of film’s meaning is conveyed through Burton’s use of colours, camera angles, symbolic codes and material’s intertextuality.

THAT OTHERNESS OF YOURS



First of all, a panning aerial shot reveals a suburban location where families reside in evenly distanced pastel-colour houses and live seemingly perfect lives. Their cars are equally colourful, and so are their accessories and even the food they eat; men go to work while women handle household activities and pamper themselves. The picturesque town is a place where people of the same social class gather and know each other...or do they, really? It is a 1950’s suburban existence which, despite its colourful exterior, is rather blank, unstable and unwilling to welcome change in its core. Although younger generation is seen as more rebellious in their appearance (wearing T-shirts and jeans) and behaviour, it still comforts to the same set of values without questioning those. Edward’s arrival thus interrupts and confronts this false utopian narrative, causing interest and excitement as soon as Peg’s car pulls in town. Overwhelmed neighbours soon invite themselves for a traditional barbecue and having met Edward call him “so different “and “mysterious”, and yet he is mutely observed as the Other and therefore a threat. Moreover, Edward comes across as pale, clumsy and rather gothic, hence not conforming to the certain image his new-found friends find normal. Giving the impression of acceptance towards the newcomer they start calling him Eddy, change his clothes and introduce their ethics, emphasizing on the “nice thing to do” and the “correct thing to do”. Ironically, it is Avon lady Peg Boggs who seemed as the most caring and human resident of the society proclaiming: “it’s all about blending in” whilst trying to conceal Edward’s facial scars. And it is, indeed, either blending in or eternal exile from the suburb where the interior is much darker and frostier than what its domestic outlook suggests at first glance. Burton’s outlandish character hence proves that invaders are not always extraterrestrial while, in fact, Edward is simply a minority and therefore forced to change in order to become part of the mainstream – speaking to those who have ever felt alienated among their own kind.

Edward’s discourse is set to confront the viewer not only through film’s binary oppositions of colour, but also through its symbolic codes: although we know that Edward wasn’t born, his creator thought of humanizing him when noticing a heart-shaped cookie and drawing it towards Ed’s chest. He acts as any other human and bares emotions - either pain, love or anger – yet remains a misunderstood outsider, a villain against his own will and, as Burton explains himself

“[...] a character who wants to touch but can’t, who was both creative and destructive. I think a lot of people feel that way to some degree, because it’s frustrating and sad to feel a certain way but for it not to come through (Burton, in Salisbury, 1995:87)”

In response, Burton creates another contrast and questions humanity of the kinky suburban community whilst highlighting its inability to see clearly through the narrow windows of the town’s indistinguishable residences. Christmas theme is equally symbolic in contest and shows that Edward is cast out community when no one should be alone - abolishing not only the holiday spirit, but also proving that traditions are often cherished until selfishness and personal gain take over. All in all, the society Edward encounters is as fake as the artificial snow decorating its festive rooftops and he runs shredding the given white shirt which was meant to make him look ‘normal’, to be one of them. Subsequently, Burton toys with colours once more – denying white as the colour of purity.

There is enough power in Edward to charge the film with energy and poignancy. The creature with scissors is multi-layered and complex enough as a symbol to invite multiple, and conflicting, interpretations (Bassil-Morozow, 2010:16).

Edward Scissorhands is, after all, not only a fantasy tale about a likeable misfit who happens to have scissors for hands, but also a critique of the American suburban community which often fails to recognize talent and creativity. It masterfully explores destructive power of the social order which has a tendency to evolve into a powerful villain in fighting those who actually require support & encouragement. Subsequently, Burton proves that in a battle of good and evil the side with a white flag is not always representing a hero, whereas the one wearing black is not necessarily a villain. Likewise, otherness in the society might appear somewhat scary and unwelcoming on the outside, but - as seen in Edward Scissorhands – be humble, creative and kind on the inside, and by no means should result in alienation of the individual whose only sin is being different.

Bibliography:

Aguirre, M. (2000) “Narrative Structure, Liminality, Self-Similarity: the Case of Gothic Fiction”, in Bloom, C. (2007) Gothic Horror: A Guide for Students and Readers. Basingstoke: Palgrave/Macmillan

Bassil-Morozow, H. (2010) Tim Burton: The Monster and the Crowd. East Sussex: Routledge

Salisbury, M. (1995) Burton on Burton. London: Faber and Faber Limited

Filmography:

Edward Scissorhands (Burton, 1990, USA)

Sunday, 24 April 2011


Blue Valentine (2010)

Boy meets girl. They fall in love. 6 years later the fireworks end.

Yet Blue Valentine is not a typical Hollywood produced relationship drama and certainly not a common pick for lovers’ day. First-time director Derek Cianfrance casts carefully selected Ryan Gosling as his leading man Dean alongside Michelle William’s Cindy to portray a story of two people uniting for a 6-year journey only to part ways having nothing in common left. The choice of actors is remarkable – Cianfrance had to convince Williams to take the part and it almost feels like Cindy’s character has been created with her in mind. Gosling, on the other hand, comes out of his shell to prove that he is now a mature actor ready to challenge the acting elite and that there’s more to him than 15 minutes of fame gained in the Mickey Mouse Club and The Notebook. It never feels like neither Gosling nor Williams are acting and their performance onscreen might be easily confused with a silent observation of neighbours next door. But what if it turned out to be a mirror of your own failed relationships (?) – that’s one question not easy to ignore during film’s running time.

Blue Valentine is charming in its simplicity and leaves out exaggerated love expressions in favour of understated middle-class romance. Nevertheless, Gosling’s melancholic performance of You Always Hurt the Ones You Love alongside William’s tap-dancing won’t leave anyone longing for a more magical love expression. What the film lacks is explanation of why the relationship between Cindy and Dean was short lived – although Cianfrance’s filmmaking debut acknowledges that there won’t always be answers to all the questions beginning with ‘why’. The story of couple’s journey is therefore left to viewer’s imagination while the narrative cuts between scenes of their first meeting and the growing distance in present day. Sometimes relationships work, sometimes they don’t, and fireworks end. And Cianfrance has definitely has found the right color to deliver the message.



Rutterfly Rating: R R R R R

Memorable Moment: You Always Hurt The Ones You Love performance

:

Sunday, 13 March 2011


Winter's Bone (2010)

Directed By: Debra Granik

Apart from leaving a very bitter taste in one's mouth, the film will also remind it's viewers how lucky they are not to experience one of those winters in their lives.
Not be be confused with a feel-good movie.

Rutterfly Rating: R R R (although Lawrence's Oscar nomination is well deserved)

Memorable Moment: Teardrop's final scene